Hardwood Floor Resurfacing vs Refinishing: What’s the Difference?
Contact Us
Are you worried about the appearance of your floors and wondering about the ideal solution? Hardwood floor resurfacing or refinishing is considered the best way to restore the luster to the floors.
Hardwood floors add warmth and elevate the appearance of your space, and they are durable. Choosing between resurfacing and refinishing can be confusing, as they differ in terms of cost, time, and the duration of the work.
Floor resurfacing involves applying a new layer of material over your existing flooring. Whereas refinishing consists of sanding the surface and applying a new stain or finish.
In this blog, we will explore the differences between hardwood floor resurfacing and refinishing. We will further discuss when you should choose one over the other, how to decide which is more suitable for your wood floors, and maintenance tips.
Start reading!
Hardwood floor resurfacing, also known as screening and recoating or buff-and-recoat, is a gentler method. It rejuvenates the existing finish of your hardwood floors. It is suitable for floors that show slight damage but are structurally sound.
Let us understand how to resurface wood floors:
• Deep Cleaning: The floor is initially cleaned thoroughly to remove dirt, dust, and other debris that could affect the finish.
• Light abrasion: In this step, a specific device uses an abrasive screen to gently scrape the existing surface finish. It forms a microscopic texture, enabling the new coat to stick correctly and preventing it from sanding down to the bare wood.
• Application of a new finish coat: One or more new coats of polyurethane or another suitable finish are applied directly over the prepared existing coating.
Refinishing engineered wood floors involves sanding the wood to its natural state, applying stain, and then sealing it with a new finish. It is a thorough and intrusive method that renovates your floors by sanding them down to the raw wood.
Can engineered wood floors be refinished? The answer is yes!
It is a preferred choice if the floors have scratches, dents, or other imperfections. Hardwood floor refinishing gives floors a fresh look and eliminates the hassle of floor replacement. It offers an opportunity to refresh your space and allows you to change the color with a new stain, highlighting the natural grain.
Let us explore how to refinish engineered wood floors:
• Refinishing involves the Sanding Process: The existing finish is sanded off, and any existing surface damage is smoothed out. Depending on how beat-up the floors are, this might take a few rounds of sanding.
• Filling when required: Cracks, openings, or other significant wood defects are filled with wood filler to achieve a seamless surface.
• Staining: If you want a different hue, you can apply a stain to change the color of your flooring.
• Protective Finish: Ultimately, several coats of a protective finish are applied to seal the wood and give your floors a sleek appearance. You can choose from oil-based, water-based, or natural finishes, based on your preference.
When it comes to maintaining your hardwood floors, understanding the primary distinctions between refinishing and resurfacing is necessary.
Refinishing is a more comprehensive procedure in which the existing finish is completely removed before a new layer is added. It is ideal for floors exhibiting notable wear, deep scratches, or blemishes.
Resurfacing is usually a quicker and more affordable process, whereas refinishing offers a long-lasting result that addresses severe damage.
Understanding these distinctions helps homeowners select the most suitable flooring method.
Generally, refinishing leads to a more durable finish than resurfacing. It happens as the sanding method removes the wood’s surface layer, allowing the new finish to adhere more effectively.
On the other hand, hardwood resurfacing applies a fresh finish over the existing surface, which may not be as durable.
Hardwood refinishing provides greater options to elevate the appearance of your wooden floor. Sanding the surface lets you choose a new color or finish for your floor. It helps you entirely change the appearance of your area.
Whereas in resurfacing, the new finish layer does not cover any hidden flaws or change the wood’s color.
Refinishing and resurfacing can both be disruptive processes, as they require sanding and the application of new finishes to your wooden floor.
Refinishing is generally more intrusive, as it involves heavy machinery and may take longer to complete.
On the other hand, resurfacing is a faster, less invasive procedure because it does not involve sanding the wood’s surface.
Engineered wood floor refinishing focuses on correcting surface flaws, such as minor scratches, dullness, or a worn-out finish. It revamps the look but does not repair significant damage below the surface.
Whereas the resurfacing process addresses both aesthetic and fundamental structural issues, providing a more thorough restoration. It is ideal for wooden floors that have significant cracks and damage, irregularities, or loose planks.
Refinishing is perfect for structurally sound floors that lack shine or show minor scratches.
On the other hand, resurfacing is ideal for floors with deep scratches, warped planks, or underlying structural problems that exceed cosmetic damage.
Refinishing revives the luster and color of hardwood floors, giving aged floors a rejuvenated, modern appearance.
Whereas resurfacing significantly rejuvenates floors that appeared irreparable, providing them with renewed durability.
When considering hardwood floor resurfacing and refinishing, cost is a significant factor that can influence your decision. The expenses for each process vary based on the extent of the work, the materials used, and the condition of your floors.
Wondering how much it costs to resurface wood floors?
Resurfacing involves more extensive labor and materials, as it usually requires replacing broken boards and strengthening floor stability. As a result, wood floor resurfacing costs more, with prices varying from $15 – $20+/sq. Ft. or higher. It is based on the complexity and the level of repairs required.
Conversely, refinishing is more affordable, as it mainly involves sanding the existing wood, addressing minor flaws, and applying a new finish. The average cost to refinish wood floors ranges from $3 to $8 per square foot.
Thus, refinishing becomes an appealing choice for floors that have lost their initial shine or show scratches and damage.
Some additional factors may influence the total expense of services. These include –
• Type of hardwood
• The area concerned
• Whether you employ experts or choose a do-it-yourself method
Resurfacing requires a larger initial investment as it can prolong the life of badly damaged floors. Refinishing is an affordable way to refresh the look of floors that are in decent condition.
Choosing between resurfacing and refinishing hardwood floors depends on the condition of your floors and the results you want.
Both techniques enhance the appearance and durability of your wooden floors, but each has distinct circumstances.
Here we will discuss when to resurface an engineered wood floor:
• Structural Issues Are Present: If your hardwood floors are warped, cupped, or uneven boards, or if certain planks are loose or damaged, resurfacing is a more suitable option. Fix warped wood floors having significant wear or damage with resurfacing. It requires fixing or replacing boards and addressing foundational structural issues.
• Deep Scratches or Stains: Resurfacing is advisable when your flooring shows severe scratches, persistent stains, or damage that extends beyond the surface layer. It addresses problems that basic sanding cannot resolve.
• Older Floors Needing Major Restoration: If your hardwood floors are old and have experienced extensive wear, resurfacing can rejuvenate them by addressing both appearance and structural concerns.
Here we will discuss when to refinish wood floors –
• Surface Wear and Minor Scratches: If your hardwood floors are structurally sound but have minor scratches and scuffs, refinishing is the most affordable option. It strips away the upper finish layer and adds a new coating, rejuvenating the floor’s natural appeal.
• You Want a Quick Refresh: Refinishing is usually quicker and less disruptive than resurfacing. If you want to refresh your floors quickly without major renovations, refinishing is the solution.
• Routine Maintenance: Frequent refinishing every couple of years helps preserve the protective coating on your floors. It enables you to avoid more severe damage and prolongs the lifespan of your hardwood.
When considering the revival of your hardwood floors, two main choices typically arise: resurfacing and refinishing. Every method comes with its own procedures, expenses, and skill demands.
Choosing whether to handle the project on your own (DIY) or to employ a professional is a crucial decision influenced by various factors.
Here’s a detailed look at what to consider for both resurfacing and refinishing:
DIY: Refinishing hardwood floors can be a feasible DIY task for homeowners with some background in home improvement. It is especially applicable if the floors require only minor sanding and a fresh coat of finish. Resurfacing, which often involves board replacement and significant repairs, usually necessitates skilled expertise.
Professional: Professionals use specialized tools and extensive experience to ensure uniform sanding, smooth repairs, and a perfect finish. Experts are skilled at managing unforeseen issues such as tough stains, warped boards, or uneven subfloors.
DIY: Choosing the DIY approach can reduce labor costs, but you have to buy multiple tools, such as sanders, buffers, and safety equipment, and have all the materials. Errors may result in additional costs or the need for expert assistance.
Professional: Engaging a professional involves higher initial costs but can prevent costly mistakes and yield lasting outcomes. Professionals might obtain higher-quality materials at reduced costs and finish the task more quickly.
DIY: Refinishing or resurfacing floors on your own takes considerable time. Getting ready, sanding, making repairs, and applying the final touches can require several days. It takes longer if you choose the DIY option.
Professional: An expert team finishes the task faster and more effectively, reducing disturbances to your home.
DIY: Refinishing involves heavy machinery that can be hard to manage, while resurfacing might require saws and other power tools. Adequate air circulation, dust control, and safety equipment are crucial. Lack of expertise increases the chances of accidents or substandard outcomes.
Professional: Experts come with the necessary equipment and safety measures in place. They manage hazardous substances and control dust and fumes efficiently.
DIY: With DIY methods, there is a high chance of inconsistent sanding, noticeable seams, or incorrect finish application. It may undermine the floor’s look and durability.
Professional: An experienced professional will provide a more reliable, long-lasting, and visually appealing result that can increase your home’s value.
Cleaning and maintenance are crucial for preserving your hardwood floors. Always consult the manufacturer’s instructions for the safe and most efficient cleaning methods.
Here are some practical wood floor maintenance tips to help you protect your investment and enjoy stunning floors.
You must place area rugs at entryways on hardwood floors to trap dirt and moisture. Use rug pads compatible with hardwood floors to prevent slipping and protect the finish.
Furniture legs may create scratches and dents in hardwood floors over time. Attach felt pads to the base of every furniture leg to prevent damage.
High heels may dent wooden floors, and pet nails can cause scratches. Make sure individuals remove their shoes and keep their pets’ nails trimmed.
Hardwood reacts adversely to water, and excessive moisture can cause warping or color changes. Utilize a moist mop and promptly dry the area after cleaning.
Use pH-neutral hardwood cleaning products to maintain the finish. You must avoid harsh cleaners or products containing ammonia or bleach, as they may damage the finish and cause scratches.
Regularly sweep or vacuum your hardwood floors with a soft-bristle attachment. It will help to remove dirt and debris that may lead to micro-scratches.
Refinishing and resurfacing are both viable options for restoring the beauty and functionality of your hardwood floors. If your floors are beginning to show signs of wear or require a new finish to enhance their look, you must make the right choice.
The choice between refinishing and resurfacing wood floors depends on the condition of your floor, your budget, and your aesthetic and longevity preferences. Careful consideration of all these factors is essential before deciding.
It is essential to consult a professional flooring contractor if you are unsure which option best suits your requirements.
At European Flooring, we ensure your hardwood floors endure for a lifetime through our top-notch services. We offer personalized solutions for your flooring challenges, tailored to your needs.
Reach out to us and restore beauty with the proper method!
1. How much does it cost to resurface wood floors compared to refinishing?
The cost of wood floor resurfacing exceeds that of refinishing due to the extra labor and materials needed. Resurfacing expenses range from $15 to over $20 per square foot, based on the level of repairs required. Refinishing is more affordable, costing $2 to $5 per square foot. The precise cost varies based on factors such as floor condition, wood type, and area size.
2. Can I resurface wood floors without sanding?
Total resurfacing involves sanding to achieve a smooth, uniform surface before adding new finishes. If your floors just need a slight update, specific products and methods allow gentle chemical etching or buffing in place of standard sanding. This method is most effective for floors that show minor wear and have no structural problems.
3. Is it possible to resurface engineered wood floors?
Yes, engineered wood floors can be resurfaced, but it depends on the thickness of the top veneer. Provided the wear layer is sufficiently thick, light sanding and refinishing may be carried out. For thinner veneers, it is advisable to use only light resurfacing techniques, such as screening and recoating, to prevent damage to the engineered surface.
4. How do I know if my floors need resurfacing or just refinishing?
Resurfacing is the preferred option if your hardwood floors show deep scratches, warped planks, or structural issues. For floors in decent condition with surface scratches, a lack of shine, or slight blemishes, refinishing is often adequate. An expert evaluation will help you in identifying the ideal remedy for your unique circumstances.